Significant Risks For Payday Loans |
|
Borrowers of
payday loans mostly encounter
problems with cash flow with almost no lower cost borrowing options. Also some payday lenders do a minimal analysis of the borrower's ability to repay either at the start of the payday loans or during refinancing, for which only a current pay stub or proof of a regular income source and evidence of a checking account are required. Many payday lenders use scoring models and consultations with nationwide databases to track bounced checks and those with outstanding payday loans. Generally payday lenders don't gather and analyze information about a borrower's total indebtedness or inputs from major national credit bureaus. Moreover a substantive review of a borrower's credit history is generally not done. A borrower's limited financial capacity, unsecured credit and limited underwriting analysis of a borrower's ability to repay the payday loans combine to create a major credit risk for insured depository institutions. The most damaging setback so far was a federal regulator in attempting to cease payday loans that charge borrowers interest rates capable of exceeding 1000%. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency that monitors banks holding federal charters directed financial institutions and banks to discontinue short-term high interest cash advances or payday loans through their offices. While not putting an end to payday loans, it can stunt the industry's overwhelming growth with a strong warning to federally chartered banks that their regulator would prefer them to avoid alliances enabling payday lenders to maneuver restrictions on their practices in certain US states. Payday loans can be for as little as two weeks at a large fee and required to be paid back on the borrower's next payday, as the name indicates. The high effective interest rates on the loans have triggered protests from consumer advocates and concern from regulators. The growth has been facilitated by the payday loans lending industry's ability to escape state usury laws and laws for specifically keeping down payday loan rates. Payday lenders, including check-cashing businesses and pawnshops, get around the laws through alliances with federally chartered banks exempt from the state usury laws. The argument by the payday loan industry is that payday loans offer fast cash in crunch situations with the terms clearly disclosed. Growing pressure from consumer groups on regulators has resulted in the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) coming down this year on several banks in the business. Insured depository institutions can have pay payday lending programs directly implemented by their own employees or through third party arrangements. In case of the latter, there typically is an agreement for the institution to fund payday loans offered through the third party. Also included in the arrangement is the sale of the payday loans and servicing rights to the loans to the third party. Institutions may also depend on the third party for extra services normally provided by the bank like collections, advertising and encouraging applications. Improper management of the third party arrangements can substantially increase risks of transaction, legal and reputation for the institutions. According to federal law, federal and state-chartered insured depository institutions dealing in payday loans to out of state borrowers have the authority to export favorable interest rates per the laws of the state that the bank is located in. Thus a state-chartered bank is permitted to charge interest on payday loans to out of state borrowers at rates applicable to the state of the bank's origin, irrespective of usury limitations of the state laws of the borrower's residence. However reputation risks are increased for the institutions in case of certain arrangements with payday lenders, including those for originating payday loans on terms not directly offered by the payday lender. Payday loans are a specialized lending alternative excluded for state non-member institutions and most frequently originated by specialized non-bank firms according to state regulation. High levels of transaction risks are involved in payday loans owing to large loan volumes, document handling and flow of loan funds between the institution and third party originators. Due to payday loans being underwritten off-site, another risk is that agents or employees may misuse information about the loans or hike credit risk through failure to conform to establish underwriting guidelines. |
